EAA Penalties and Enforcement
EAA penalties and enforcement: what Article 30 requires, who checks services, verified penalty ranges in Germany and Ireland, what a complaint leads to.
Short answer
The European Accessibility Act leaves penalties to each EU country: Article 30 requires them to be effective, proportionate and dissuasive, to come with corrective action, and to reflect how serious the failure is and how many people it affects. National authorities check services, follow up complaints and verify fixes. Amounts differ widely — for example up to €100,000 in Germany and up to €60,000 or 18 months in prison on indictment in Ireland.
- Penalties set by
- Each EU country (Article 30)
- Germany (BFSG § 37)
- Up to €100,000 / €10,000
- Ireland (S.I. 636/2023)
- Up to €60,000 or 18 months
- Services checked under
- Article 23
- Enforceable since
- 28.06.2025
Primary sources
- Directive (EU) 2019/882 on the accessibility requirements for products and services — EUR-Lex
- § 37 Bußgeldvorschriften — Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz (BFSG)
- S.I. No. 636/2023 — European Union (Accessibility Requirements of Products and Services) Regulations 2023 — Irish Statute Book
- Ν. 4994/2022, άρθρο 26 — Διοικητικές κυρώσεις
EAA Penalties and Enforcement
The European Accessibility Act sets the requirements once for the whole EU, but enforcement is national. Each country designates the authorities, sets the penalties and runs the procedure. This guide explains what the Directive fixes, what varies, and what to keep ready. It cites only figures we could read in the national law itself; for any other country, check the act that transposes the Directive there.
What the Directive fixes
Article 30 — penalties. Each country lays down the rules on penalties and makes sure they are applied. They must be "effective, proportionate and dissuasive" and be accompanied by effective remedial action when an operator does not comply. They must take into account the extent of the non-compliance, including its seriousness, the number of non-compliant products or services and the number of people affected.
Article 23 — services. Each country sets up procedures to check that services comply (including any disproportionate-burden assessment), to follow up complaints or reports, and to verify that the operator has taken the corrective action. The authorities and their decisions must be made known to the public.
Article 29 — action by people and organisations. Consumers can bring cases before national courts or authorities, and public bodies, private associations or organisations with a legitimate interest — such as disability organisations — can act on their behalf.
Products are covered by market surveillance (Articles 19 to 22): authorities can require corrective action and, if that fails, restrict or withdraw a product from the market.
Verified examples
| Country | National law | Authority | Penalties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Germany | Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz (BFSG), § 37 | Marktüberwachungsstelle der Länder für die Barrierefreiheit von Produkten und Dienstleistungen (MLBF), Magdeburg | Up to €100,000 for offering a non-compliant service or placing a non-compliant product on the market and for CE-marking breaches; up to €10,000 for other breaches, such as missing information |
| Ireland | S.I. No. 636/2023 | Several, including the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission | On indictment, a fine up to €60,000 or up to 18 months in prison, or both; on summary conviction, a class A fine or up to 12 months |
| Greece | Law 4994/2022, Article 26 | Market surveillance authorities; the telecoms regulator for electronic communications; the broadcasting authority for media services | Administrative sanctions set by proportionality, considering the extent of the breach, the type and size of the business and its cooperation; the article itself does not fix amounts |
Penalties are only one tool. In every system the first step is usually an order to fix the problem within a deadline, and a service can ultimately be restricted. The most expensive outcome for a business is often not the fine but the remediation done in a hurry under a deadline.
What a complaint leads to
The exact procedure is national, but it follows the steps Article 23 requires:
- A user or organisation reports a barrier to the authority — or the authority selects the service for a check.
- The authority asks the provider for information: the published accessibility information (Annex V), test records, any disproportionate-burden assessment.
- If the service does not comply, the provider is told what to fix and by when.
- The authority verifies the fix. Penalties come into play when the provider does not comply, does not cooperate, or the breach is serious.
What makes a check more likely
No authority publishes a target list, but the Directive and national laws point to the obvious: consumer services with many users (shops, banks, transport, telecoms), barriers that block a task such as payment or sign-in, missing accessibility information — the easiest gap to see — and complaints, especially repeated ones or ones made through disability organisations.
What to keep ready
If an authority asks, these are the documents that answer it:
- The published accessibility information required by Article 13 and Annex V, with its date.
- Test records: what was tested, against which standard (EN 301 549 v3.2.1 / WCAG 2.1 AA), how, when, what was found and what was fixed.
- A remediation plan for known issues, with dates and the alternatives offered meanwhile.
- Any disproportionate-burden assessment (Article 14), the date you informed the authority, and evidence that you renew it at least every five years.
- Microenterprise evidence, if you rely on that exemption: head count and turnover or balance sheet total.
- A record of user reports and how you answered them.
Compliance costs less than enforcement
The cheapest time to fix an accessibility barrier is when the page or component is built. Retrofitting under an authority's deadline costs more, and the business risk is the service itself, not only the fine. A practical order of work:
- Fix the five common barriers — link and button names, form labels, alt text, page language — which most sites have.
- Make the key journeys usable with keyboard and screen reader, including payment and third-party widgets.
- Publish honest accessibility information and a way to report problems.
- Keep testing on every release.
Our "EAA Compliance Checklist for Websites" turns this into concrete checks, and RankProof's free accessibility scanner, colour contrast checker and statement generator cover the automated part. This guide is not legal advice; national rules change, so check the current text of the law in each country where you offer the service.
Free tools on this topic
Guides on this topic
Research data on this topic
Start with a free check
Run the free audit or pick one of the tools — no account, and every result explains what to fix.
Try Free Scan