Competitor SEO Analysis: Check and Compare Sites
Competitor SEO analysis: a free, repeatable method to find who ranks for your searches, compare authority, keyword and content gaps, and pick gaps worth a page.
Short answer
Competitor SEO analysis starts with the domains that rank for your target searches, not with your business rivals. Compare how strong those domains are, which searches and topics they cover that you do not, and how their pages are built — then keep only the gaps you can realistically win, usually narrower searches where the top 10 is weaker.
- Who counts as a competitor
- Domains in the top 10 for your target searches
- Free data for your own site
- Search Console queries and positions
- Gaps worth a page
- Matching intent and winnable difficulty
Competitor SEO Analysis: Check and Compare Sites
Competitor analysis is useful for one thing: finding searches and topics you can realistically win. An inventory of everything a competitor does is not the goal. This guide walks through a method that needs no paid tools, with real results from RankProof's free tools as examples.
Who your search competitors really are
Your search competitors are the domains in the top 10 for the searches you want, whether or not they sell what you sell. A publisher, a forum or a public authority can hold the position you are after.
A quick way to map them:
- List 15–20 searches you want to rank for. Your Search Console Performance report is the best start: it shows the queries you already appear for and your average position.
- Search each one in the country and language you target, signed out or in a private window, so the results are less personalised.
- Note the domains in the top 10 for each search.
- Count how often each domain appears. Those that show up for many of your searches are your real competitors; the rest are one-offs.
Expect a mix. Some domains are strong across the whole topic, others own one narrow corner — and the narrow ones are usually easier to compete with.
How to check a competitor with free tools
Pick one search you care about and one competitor page that ranks above you for it. Run each check below on that page and on your own page for the same search, then compare the two results side by side. Every check runs on one URL, takes about a minute and needs no account.
- Whole-page audit. Run the free website audit on the competitor's page. It runs 133 checks and scores the page by category: on-page SEO, speed, mobile, security, accessibility and more. Compare category by category, not the overall score: a failure you have and they do not is a concrete fix. It audits one page, so it says nothing about the rest of their site.
- Title and description. The title and meta description checker shows the title and meta description in the page's HTML, with their length in characters and estimated pixels. The wording shows which phrase they target and how they ask for the click. It cannot tell whether Google shows that text or rewrites it.
- Structured data. The structured data checker lists the JSON-LD types on the page, such as Product, Article or Organization, and flags markup that does not parse or lacks basic fields. A type they use and you lack is a gap you can close. It does not tell you whether Google shows a rich result for them, and markup added by scripts is not read.
- Speed. The page speed analysis gives a lab score with the biggest opportunities, plus the real-visitor Core Web Vitals when Chrome has collected enough visits for the page or the site. Compare the real-visitor figures when both sites have them, since lab scores vary between runs. Speed is one signal among many, so a faster page is not sure to rank higher.
- Broken links. The broken links checker tests up to 100 links on the page and lists the ones that fail. Many broken links on a page that ranks well suggest it is not kept up to date, which is an opening if your page on the topic is current. It checks status codes only, so a missing page that answers 200 is not caught.
Write one line per check: what they do better, what you do better, what you will change. Save the list with the date: running the same checks every month or two is the simplest way to track what a competitor changes. Keep it next to the keyword and content gaps from the sections below.
These checks cannot show a competitor's traffic, their number of backlinks or where they rank for every search. Those figures can only be estimated from outside a site, and none of the checks above estimates them. For rankings, look at the results yourself, as in the previous section, and at your own Search Console data.
How strong they are
Authority is the first filter. RankProof's domain comparison returns a 0–10 link-authority score, based on a public PageRank-style measure, for your domain and one competitor side by side. A gap of several points means their pages usually win a close contest. It does not mean you cannot rank: Google ranks pages for a search, not domains in general.
Keyword difficulty applies the same idea to a single search: it averages the authority of the domains in today's top 10. On 7 October 2026 we ran four common tool searches through RankProof's keyword tool, for the United States:
| Search | Demand band (estimate) | Difficulty | Intent |
|---|---|---|---|
| website accessibility checker | 10K–100K | 72 · Very hard | Commercial |
| keyword difficulty checker | 1K–10K | 69 · Hard | Commercial |
| accessibility statement generator | 100–1K | 67 · Hard | Commercial |
| free seo audit | 1K–10K | 60 · Hard | Commercial |
Every one of them is held by strong domains. That is normal for broad searches, and it is why the next step matters more than the headline keyword. The demand band is an order of magnitude from public signals, not a count of searches.
Keyword gaps
A keyword gap is a search where competitors rank and you do not. Free ways to find them:
- Their sitemap (usually
/sitemap.xml) and main navigation show which topics they built pages for. - A
site:search on a topic, such assite:example.com accessibility statement, shows which of their pages Google returns for it. - Their titles and headings show the phrasing they target.
- Your own Search Console queries with many impressions but positions beyond 20 are gaps on your side: Google already links you with the topic, but no page of yours answers it well.
Then filter hard. Keep a gap only if:
- the intent matches a page you can build — a comparison search needs a comparison, not a product page;
- the difficulty is within reach — usually a narrower phrasing, a specific use case, or your own country and language rather than the US head term;
- you can add something the current top 10 does not: data, an example, a clearer answer.
Content gaps
Pick one search and open the top three results. Compare them with your page section by section: which questions they answer that you skip, which examples, data or steps they give, and when they were last updated.
RankProof's content gap tool does part of this for you. It reads your page and up to three competitor pages, measures how similar the texts are, and lists the topics and phrases the competitors cover and your page does not. Treat that list as a checklist, not as words to paste in: Google asks for content written for people, and a page that repeats its competitors' phrases adds nothing new.
Technical comparison
Run the free website audit on your page and on a competitor's comparable page, and compare category by category — speed, mobile, security, accessibility — rather than the overall score. Look for failures you have and they do not. For reference, our own homepage scored 92/100 on 7 October 2026: SEO basics 97, accessibility 95, speed 75, AI search readiness 73.
The technology checker shows which content system, framework or CDN a page runs on, which explains some differences in speed and structure. A technical gap rarely explains a ranking gap on its own: Google describes page experience as one signal among many, and the relevance and quality of the content come first.
Their messaging
Search ads are public. The Google Ads Transparency Center lists the ads an advertiser has run, by region. The wording a competitor keeps paying for shows which benefits and problems they believe matter to your shared audience — useful input for your own titles and descriptions, not text to copy.
Following changes over time
There is no free way to track a competitor's rankings continuously. Track your own in Search Console, repeat the manual top-10 check for your key searches every month or two, and note who moved. When a competitor climbs, look at what changed on their page: new sections, a fresher date, better examples.
A plan for the first month
- Week 1: map competitors from 15–20 searches and compare authority.
- Week 2: list keyword gaps, then filter by intent and difficulty to five or fewer.
- Week 3: for each kept gap, compare the top three pages and outline a page that answers better.
- Week 4: audit your own key pages, fix the failures competitors do not have, and publish the first new page.
What not to do
- Do not copy text or structure wholesale. Copied content does not rank, and it can infringe copyright.
- Do not judge by one number. A domain with lower authority can outrank a stronger one with a page that answers the search better.
- Do not chase every gap. A short list you can win beats a long list you cannot.
Start with a free check
Run the free audit or pick one of the tools — no account, and every result explains what to fix.
Try Free Scan